Improving workflows for human resources

A case study in user-centered design

The problem

The Human Resources department wanted to improve their existing PeopleSoft solution for managing employee info so that more of the tasks could be delegated to low-level management.

Original product

Original product: Lots of distractions and minimal functionality.

Original product 2

Original product: The help text took up a lot of space, but did not address the users's needs.

“I select several things, and hope that I will be taken to just what I need.”User feedback during a usability session on the existing product

My role

I was asked by HR to suggest changes needed to meet their goals. They had in mind a wizard approach like TurboTax. I was the only designer and hand-picked subject matter experts across the organization.

This case study briefly covers the user-centered design process that I followed, the resulting solution, and usability metrics showing the improvements.

UCD Process

Interview Stakeholders

In order to understand their goals, the project constraints (timeline, resources, technologies, etc.), and to get to know everyone.

Select Subject Matter Experts

Reached out to low-level managers across the organization from different departments and with varied levels of technical experience, and varied levels of experience with the existing solution.

Create Project Plan

Defined the tasks and timelines.

Heuristic Evaluation

Performed heuristic evaluation of the existing solution to determine how to best create scripts for user observation sessions.

User Observation

Facilitated user observation sessions where I remotely observed users attempt to complete specific tasks.

Survey

At the end of the sessions, the user filled out a SUS survey to get data on the usability of the current solution.

Workflow Analysis

I performed workflow analysis to summarize what I had learned and validate. These were used to inform the global navigation, workflows, and areas where online help would be beneficial.

Workflow Analysis

Workflow Analysis

Debrief & Brainstorm

Reviewed the results with stakeholders and brainstormed concepts for improvement.

Design

Iteratively designed in parallel with usability testing:

Iterative Usability Testing

Conducted three rounds of usability testing, with each round evaluating updates made based on feedback from the prior round.

Collaborated with stakeholders the entire time and invited them to be silent observers at the testing sessions.

At the end of each testing session, the user filled out a SUS survey to get data on the usability of the current design and better understand how close we were to meeting our usability criteria.

Final Product

Final product

Final Product: Wizard pattern to guide infrequent users and provide help where needed using progressive disclosure.

Final product

Final Product: Added a sidebar to summarize changes made, indicate where they are in the process, and navigate asynchronously.

Final product

Final Product: New review page before submitting changes.

Results

The System Usability Scale (SUS) raw score increased from 60% to 97%.

SUS raw score

SUS raw score

Quotes from users

Quotes above from users

“Mark was assigned a project that required him to jump right in, while he was working remotely, with a team that he had never met before, on a domain he has never worked on before.” Charles Fusco: HR Technology Lead